Midsemester Night's Dream concludes as Charlie and Matthew feel the pressure of the outside world close in on their dorm room romance. The two freshmen find that their hard kept secrets cannot stay hidden forever, forcing them to make a bold decision. "Filthy Animals" begins as Charlie and Matthew feel emboldened to have a little fun in their shared dorm bathroom, playing around in the showers when they think they're alone. But when their RA, Peter, finds evidence of their Promethean natures, they face a threat they hoped would never surface. The two boys end up finding support and answers from a familiar face, reminding them that they are not alone in this big, new world.